The Crystal Ball Series: Issue 2 – The Reckoning

The best question I’ve heard this year? When I was speaking at an event in Alberta (I heart Canadian oil and gas): a highly placed executive who doubles as a soccer mom asked me: When will the soccer moms revolt? Meaning, reject the oil and gas opposition that is making resource development more difficult, expensive, or even impossible. I asked my crystal ball.

The news isn’t pretty. 

The question reflects a theme I often hear out in oil and gas country: We will be redeemed and victorious when… gasoline prices are too high, geopolitics are negatively affected, there’s a heating fuel shortage during winter… complete the sentence with your reckoning of choice. 

I’m sorry, BT fans, my read of the crystal ball: You will soon be disappointed…

In honor of the Halloween season, here’s the second in the Crystal Ball five-part series.

Both of these things are true:

  • Oil and gas is mission-critical for economic prosperity and day-to-day living. It must be always available and always affordable.
  • My crystal ball does not foresee a reckoning where the anti-oil-and-gas public says, We were wrong! We need you!

The problem crystal ball reveals

You will soon be disappointed if you hoped opponents of oil and gas would change their minds.  Here’s why. 

My crystal ball doesn’t say this is right, or fair. The fog simply reveals that the public – including your stakeholders, shareholders, and communities – does not have a track record of suddenly appreciating the miracle of affordable, abundant energy. (Or, to be fair, water, food, roads or bridges, either.)

It matters because

Part of the industry’s business-as-usual strategy is consciously or unconsciously relying on the idea of this inevitable reckoning: The Revolt of the Soccer Moms. If it’s not going to happen, we have to do some things very differently.

The critical mistakes companies are making: 

Doubling down on education as the solution. Education as a stand-alone strategy requires a leap-of-faith that the public, and all those moms, will suddenly appreciate their energy wealth if they have more facts. Do you see this happening for water providers? Or state transportation departments?  

Seize the day.   It’s not all grim – knowing the risks allows us to plan and mitigate. Let’s break out the Magic 8 Ball now and do just that. 

  • DON’T COUNT ON IT. Let’s let go of the idea that there will be a reckoning and we will then be the beneficiaries of a hometown parade. So now what?
  • YES – DEFINITELY. Your strategy should include a pathway that engages stakeholders who will never appreciate your company’s value in providing energy. In this case, your value proposition to your stakeholders includes shared aspirations – such as civic leadership and community philanthropy. Give some thought to what else.
  • BETTER NOT TELL YOU NOW. That you should conduct a risk assessment – again.

We are here to help if you need us, just email us.

If this post was forwarded to you, you can subscribe to Both of These Things are True here.

More Articles

BlackRock’s Real 2022 Expectations, Part 1

For the last several years, BlackRock has set the pace for how investment firms will drive ESG performance at portfolio companies. (See our 2020 and 2021 notes on BlackRock.) Larry Fink’s letter to the CEOs of BlackRock’s portfolio companies in January made headlines for its focus on relationships with employees and pushback on divestiture.

Good Conflict

In the oil and gas industry, we find ourselves describing public hostility to our work in black-and-white terms, such as “fight for our lives” and “energy wars.” These characterizations serve a purpose: They unite oil and gas workers, give us a sense of shared purpose, and mobilize us to serve as industry ambassadors to the world. But could this kind of black-and-white thinking — which seems to strengthen our collective identity — also lead us to our demise? Now that’s worthy of contemplation.

What to Watch for 2022: Federal Policy

2021 ended with a whimper for the budget reconciliation package that Democrats had hoped to finish before the holidays. In this edition of Both True, I give you what to watch for regarding federal policy in 2022 — a year that begins with Democrats hoping to resuscitate their climate agenda and the midterm election season moving into full swing.